Friday 5 October 2018

Where there's smoke: Did Henry VIII's--and the nation's-- treasure leave England illegally?




The magnificent St Paul tapestry commissioned by Henry VIII for Hampton Court Palace in 1536 is a  national treasure. It was taken from London to Barcelona in the late 1960s and has remained in Spain ever since. Why was such an exceptional treasure given a license to leave this country?  The answer, it appears, is that it did not have one; that was exported illegally.  Splendid, historically important and technically innovative, the panel is currently back in London.  Spain granted its private owner a temporary license so that conservation work could be carried out by specialist dealers S Franses. They have put in on public view for the next two weeks. The final stage of conservation will then begin. The Spanish temporary license expires in February. By every relevant measures of importance, the St Paul tapestry belongs here. It should in England where it could join the National Collection at the Victoria & Albert Museum or, better still,  hang once again at Hampton Court.

Some 20-feet long, woven during the Renaissance in Brussels at the height of weavers’ skills, richly embellished with gold-wrapped thread, it is a fabulous piece that only a king could afford.  This surely was obvious to the Vigo-Sternberg-Galleries, top dealers in tapestries, where the work was seen shortly before it arrived in Spain. Its money value in 1970 was least $8,000, an additional reason an export license would have been required. (Today, on the open international market, it would be £10million or more.)  Indeed, its evident splendour and value is one reason that more recently, Spain has twice refused its owner’s application for a full export license. This far no  record that a license was requested or issued has turned up. According to the S Franses Gallery,  Wendy Hefford, tapestry specialist at the V& A when it left England and the expert most likely to be asked to judge its suitability for export, says she never saw it.    

This St Paul panel  is the  “It is the Holy Grail of Tudor Tapestries,” says Thomas P. Campbell, a former director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art and leading authority on Renaissance tapestries;  author of the brilliantly researched “Henry VIII and the Art of Majesty: Tapestries at the Tudor Court.” Originally there were nine tapestries in the St Paul set. This rare survival, all on its own, gives a vivid pictorial expression of the king’s thinking and state of mind at a tumultuous period in his reign and the country’s history--the dissolution of the monasteries.

Campbell explains that Henry VIII wished to  “present himself as head of the British church,  a religious man. He wanted to show that he was in direct succession to Abraham, Joshua, David, Moses and St. Paul.”  In this work St Paul is shown directing the burning of irreligious texts; an act  Henry VIII was then overseeing in England.  The smoke that billows up in the centre of the tapestry—wonderful and terrible-- is evidence of destruction in the service of religion and power. It is also an aesthetic and technical triumph. Go see it at the gallery. With any luck it will remain at home in England for all to see in years to come.


Tomorrow (Saturday) Campbell will be giving a lecture on Henry VIII's tapestry collection at the Royal Academy of Art. (Tickets, which are free, are available through the Franses gallery..)